Versailles to Pearl Harbor

“You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.” — Leo Tolstoy

Naval Dispatch from the Commander in Chief Pacific (CINCPAC) Announcing the Japanese Attack on Pearl Harbor, 7 December 1941, John J. Ballentine Papers

Versailles Peace Treaty

After the 1919 Versailles Treaty ended World War I, there was an understandable push to prevent a major war from ever happening again. In hindsight, though, this Long Armistice was just a break from fighting before World War II, which in the United States’ case started with Japan’s bombing of Pearl Harbor, Hawaii in 1941. The conflict started earlier in Asia (1937) and Europe (1939). How did the armistice come unraveled? For one, the dedication to peace among most of the countries allowed aggressive ones like Japan and Germany to get away with more than they otherwise would have. That appeasement is a typical starting point in many accounts of the interwar crisis. The non-aggressor nations also weren’t able to provide an effective international framework of their own between the wars. Britain led prior to World War I and the U.S. after World War II, but no one country stepped up between the wars to maintain stability.

Once the world economy started to crumble in the late 1920s, nations reverted to protectionism instead of reaffirming open trade agreements. Global trade stalled. As we saw in Chapter 8, the U.S., Britain, and Europe remained yoked together under tight monetary policy tied to the gold standard, inhibiting stimulus spending when the Depression set in. Congress passing the Smoot-Hawley Tariff in 1930 only made things worse.Interwar Period

In the United States’ case, that inward economic turn matched their diplomatic isolationism. Woodrow Wilson’s League of Nations never gained effective traction and didn’t grant itself authority to intervene militarily or economically. The U.S. didn’t join the League even though its president, Woodrow Wilson, founded it (see cartoon, below). American opponents of the League weren’t mere reactionaries; they made a solid isolationist case that membership over-committed the U.S. to intervene all over the world in conflicts that didn’t really concern Americans. That being said, the American boycott weakened the League and helped prevent it from being able to counter Japan or Germany. As we’ll see, a multitude of factors was to blame for World War II and they unfolded in two distinct regions. Japanese and German militarization created two simultaneous threats in Asia and Europe. While the two theaters overlapped and influenced each other, we’ll divide our discussion of the run-up to WWII geographically.

Gap in the Bridge (Cartoon About Absence of the USA From the League of Nations, Depicted as the Missing Keystone of the Arch, w. Cigar Symbolizing Uncle Sam Enjoying its Wealth, Leonard Raven-Hill, Punch Magazine, 1919

Gap in the Bridge (Cartoon About Absence of the USA From the League of Nations), Depicted as the Missing Keystone of the Arch, w. Cigar Symbolizing Uncle Sam Enjoying Wealth, Leonard Raven-Hill, Punch Magazine, 1919

WWII In Asia
In Asia, the U.S. and Britain were leery of Japan’s rapid industrial and military buildup. The Japanese took advantage of Europe’s preoccupation and their alliance with Britain to expand their holdings in the Pacific during WWI, especially at the expense of Germany. At the Washington Naval Conference after the war, Japan agreed to freeze the proportion of their battleship tonnage in relation to Britain and the U.S. at a 3-5-5 ratio (unlike Japan, the U.S. and Britain had to maintain two-ocean navies). However, nobody anticipated the advent of aircraft carriers (aka flat-tops), which weren’t included in the agreement. Restrictions on traditional capital ships only motivated the U.S. and Japan to put more money and research into carriers. Likewise, the Versailles Treaty’s restrictions on traditional armaments only motivated Germany to research rocketry. The U.S. also started a special Air Corps within the Army that became the Army Air Force (USAAF) and branched off into the Air Force after World War II, and they trained pilots in the Navy/Marines. While planes didn’t have a huge impact on the outcome of WWI, they evolved to the point that everyone could see future wars would be won or lost in the air. After WWI, the U.S. also scrapped over half its aging naval fleet and shrunk its standing army down to 136k.

Japanese Emperor Shōwa Hirohito

Japanese Emperor Shōwa Hirohito

Regardless of how many carriers or planes they built, Japan was slamming shut the Open Door Policy that had kept China’s spoils evenly divided amongst Japan and the West since the late 19th century. Just as the U.S. claimed all of the Western Hemisphere as its sphere of influence starting in the 1820s, Japan now countered the American Monroe Doctrine and Roosevelt Corollary with what it euphemistically called the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere. Translation: Japan was taking over Asia. They were following the same logic Alfred T. Mahan had laid out for the U.S. in the 1890s in terms of acquiring overseas territories (markets) and building a strong navy to fuel domestic industry (Chapter 3). Mahan based his theories on Britain’s rise to maritime and naval prominence and the British model, not America’s, fit Japan best. Like England, Japan was a small island country and had even fewer natural resources (some coal), but they hoped to dominate the western Pacific economically with a superior navy. They conquered Okinawa and the Ryukyu Islands in 1871 and they coveted raw materials on the Chinese mainland and in Russia’s far eastern territory.

Japanese fed themselves the usual gibberish about God liking them better than everyone else. What else could explain their racial superiority over other Asians? In Japan’s case, Emperor Hirohito lent credence to their version of Manifest Destiny but its Parliament (National Diet) and generals, led by Hideki Tōjō (prime minister starting in 1941), pursued military expansion most aggressively. There was fierce internal debate about the government’s direction and militarists asserted greater control and took charge after a 1923 earthquake. They kept communism, socialism, and republicanism at bay, moving the country toward fascism. By the 1920s, Japanese schools were denigrating the Chinese. Religious chauvinism and racism provided ideological frosting on the cake, with the main goal being economic growth.

Extent of Japanese Occupation (red) in China, ca. 1940

Extent of Japanese Occupation (red) in China, ca. 1940, U.S. Army

Chinese Buried Alive by Japanese Soldiers During Nanking Massacre, 1938, UC-Santa Barbara

Chinese Buried Alive by Japanese Soldiers During Nanking Massacre, 1938, UC-Santa Barbara

Unlike Europeans, Japanese weren’t haunted by memories of the Great War. In fact, they’d profited from WWI and their last major war was a happy memory: victory over Russia in the northwest Pacific in 1905. Now, extension of Russia’s Trans-Siberian Railway to Vladivostok was threatening Japan’s potential control of Manchuria in northeastern China. Earlier, in 1895, Japan acquired the iron and coal-rich Korean Peninsula and Formosa (Taiwan) in the First Sino-Japanese War against China’s Qing Dynasty. In 1931, hoping to offset the economic downturn of the Depression, Japan took over Manchuria, a mineral and coal-rich area with good soil for soy and barley. Roundly condemned by foreign statesmen for this act of naked aggression, the Japanese walked out on the League of Nations, but the League didn’t act to stop their Manchurian invasion. Smaller skirmishes with China ensued from 1932-37 and, while the U.S. sold them oil, scrap metal, and steel, Japan conquered most of China in 1937 in the Second Sino-Japanese War, kicking off World War II in the Pacific with attacks on Peking (Beijing) and Shanghai.

Chinese Head, Beheaded by Japanese During Nanking Massacre

Chinese Head, Beheaded by Japanese During Nanking Massacre

Following a motto of the “Three Alls” Japanese forces were instructed to “kill all, loot all, burn all” in a scorched-earth campaign. They raped, poisoned and brutalized Chinese civilians on a massive scale, just as they soon would throughout Asia. At Nanjing, they slaughtered so many in six weeks that they faced logistical challenges dealing with the corpses and eventually had to force Chinese survivors to bury the body parts themselves or to walk into their own graves to be buried alive.

Tragically, China inadvertently killed half a million of its own people when they opened the floodgates on the Yellow River in an attempt to stop the Japanese invasion. Fifteen million Chinese died in the eight-year war against Japan but they never capitulated. Japan got bogged down in China, in fact, especially after Soviet troops defeated them in Outer Mongolia in the Battles of Khalkhyn Gol in 1939.

Chemical Warfare in Sino-Japanese War, Hunan Front Near Changsha, 1941, Cabinet Printing Bureau of the Empire of Japan

Chemical Warfare in Sino-Japanese War, Hunan Front Near Changsha, 1941, Cabinet Printing Bureau of the Empire of Japan

The U.S. feigned some disapproval over the 1937 Japanese invasion of China but wasn’t put off enough to discontinue feeding the war machine. America was in a depression and needed the money. Over the course of the next few years, Japan slowly encroached further and further across Asia, taking over French-held Indochina (Vietnam, Laos & Cambodia) in 1940. At that point, the U.S. got concerned for its own oil interests in Indonesia and cut Japan off from oil, scrap metal, and steel, demanding that they retreat out of Indochina. We’ll revisit Asia after examining Europe between the wars.

Weimar Germany
History is full of mistakes that leaders and nations would correct if only they could rewind the clock. The punitive treatment of Germany at the end of WWI is an obvious example — one we’ll see the U.S. learned from and corrected after WWII. Of course, we don’t know for sure that Germany wouldn’t have caused problems for the rest of Europe even if they’d been dealt more generous terms at the Versailles Peace Conference. Drawing a simple, straight line from the Great War to Nazi Germany is overly deterministic, given that nearly fifteen years transpired in between. There’s no doubt, though, that martyrdom and vengeance fueled the Nazis’ rise. It’s impossible to understand the Nazis without understanding the context of WWI.

Hitler @ Nazi RallyWhile Germany’s invasion of Belgium in 1914 was rightfully condemned as worsening an already volatile situation, it was unfair that Germany was singled out and blamed for the Great War. Austria, for one, could’ve dealt with the Archduke’s assassination without punishing the entire Serbian population for the actions of the Black Hand terrorists (Serb army) and Britain could’ve stayed out of the war altogether. As we saw in the Great War chapter, American diplomats inserted the so-called War Guilt Clause regarding Germany, despite President Woodrow Wilson’s initial promise of lenient terms. Others have argued that the clause mentioned no such thing, and Germans played up the guilt factor to elicit international sympathy. The text reads: “The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage to which the Allied and Associated Governments and their nationals have been subjected as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies.”

Germany's Hyperinflation of 1923

Between August and November 1923, a U.S. Dollar Went From Being Worth 630,000 Deutsche Mark to 630 Billion DM.

All the losers, not just Germany, got the blame. Either way, it was unrealistic, unfair and counterproductive to expect Germany to pay the victors’ debts. Kaiser Wilhelm had to abdicate his throne, they destroyed their submarines, planes, and battleships, and Germany gave up territory in the west to France and east to the reconstituted country of Poland. Adding insult to injury, the Allies embargoed Germany for another year-and-a-half, ostracizing them just when Western Allies should’ve been propping up the struggling democracy that ruled the country in the 1920s. The Weimar Republic (or Deutsches Reich), named after the city in Germany where the new constitution was written, practiced a form of government that Britain and the U.S. should’ve been supporting since they had a stake in displacing other options. Instead, the Weimar Republic struggled to get out from under the restrictions of the Versailles Treaty. They experienced hyperinflation in the early 1920s due to the devaluation of the German Mark, recovered briefly, and then sank into a depression that exacerbated the worldwide economic slowdown of the 1930s.

French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr Valley (in the northern Rhineland), Germany’s industrial heartland, demanding payments in coal and steel to pay off Germany’s debt. Coal shortages triggered German inflation and Nazis filmed French soldiers kicking around Germans who failed to doff their caps and killing uncooperative miners and factory workers. The humiliation of the Ruhr occupation played directly into Nazis’ hands as they recruited resentful Germans in nearby Bavaria.

Hitler @ Nuremberg Rally, 1928, National Archives Collection of Foreign Records Seized, Heinrich Hoffman Collection

Hitler @ Nuremberg Rally, 1928, National Archives Collection of Foreign Records Seized, Heinrich Hoffman Collection

Germany’s erratic economy also played into Nazis’ hands. The U.S. restructured Germany’s debt under the 1924 Dawes Plan that staggered their payments, tied repayment to productivity in the German economy, and extended the reparation deadline. It also called for the withdrawal of Allied troops from the Ruhr Valley. That temporarily resolved Germany’s economic crisis and led to a brief rebound. However, the U.S. wouldn’t forgive Britain or France their debts, so those countries needed Germany’s full payments to repay America. Ultimately, the reparations just cycled back to the U.S. and Germany’s economy was increasingly tied to Western countries as they experienced their own downturns. The Dawes Plan gave way to the Young Plan, that reduced the amount owed to 122 billion Gold Marks (around $8 billion 1929 dollars), with the final installment due in 1988. These measures didn’t suffice, especially after the American Stock Market Crash of 1929 contributed to a worldwide slowdown. President Herbert Hoover declared a one-year moratorium on German debt in 1931, but that didn’t help much, either. Adding fuel to the fire — in a precursor to the Credit Default Swaps that got the world in trouble in 2008 — by 1931, Britain’s top investment banks had sold credit guarantees to investors in German debt. When Germany defaulted the British government went from surplus to debt as they bailed out their financial sector.

Weimar Republic Coat of Arms

Weimar Republic Coat of Arms

The Weimar Republic had political problems as well. Its constitution muddled the relationship between the chancellors, presidents, and Reichstag (parliament). It allowed leaders to rule without parliament’s consent in an emergency but didn’t clearly define emergency. Germany had a multi-party democracy, with each party winning seats in the Reichstag proportional to their percentage of votes. The center didn’t hold under World War I general and President Paul von Hindenburg. In the 1928 elections, the Nazis won less than 3% of the votes, but WWI flying ace Hermann Göring (Gestapo founder and head of the Luftwaffe) and Joseph Goebbels (Nazi Propaganda Minister) won seats, and Goebbels said they entered parliament like “wolves into the sheep’s pen.” By the early 1930s, the chancellors (appointed by the president) were overriding the Reichstag, culminating in Chancellor Hitler. No one party was able to establish clear rule and the far left and far right challenged the existence of the Republic upheld by Social Democrats (SPD) and the Catholic Center Party, or Zentrum. Hindenburg (an independent) temporarily dissolved parliament in 1932. Nazi Storm Troopers fought communists in the streets prior to the 1932 elections while Hitler campaigned tirelessly, averaging five speeches a day. By then, Nazis constituted a plurality in the Reichstag if not an actual majority, while polling especially well among rural Protestants. Meanwhile, Hitler dismissed media critical of him as luginpresse, or “lying press.” Nazis, to make a long story short, came to power through a combination of democratic elections, media manipulation, and street-level intimidation. Hitler still seemed like a marginal nutcase to most by 1928, but after the 1929 Crash left six million unemployed the public yearned for order amidst the chaos. Order was the Nazis’ specialty.

Rise of Nazis
Like all European countries monarchies fell at the end of WWI, Germany was volatile afterward as factions competed to fill the vacuum. The three main options were democratic capitalism (republicanism), communism and fascism — a jingoistic form of dictatorship that compels allegiance to a militaristic state. Fascism promotes order, racial superiority, and militarism. Since fascist states promise to get rid of the inefficiency, argumentation, and messiness of democracies, they’re appealing to countries undergoing the sort of trauma Germany was suffering in the late 1920s and early 30’s. Neighboring Italy also struggled after WWI. Its dictator Benito Mussolini defined fascism as, “the state which educates its citizens in civic virtue, gives them a consciousness of their mission, and welds them into unity.” Adolf Hitler Saluting Followers

Adolf Hitler’s paramilitary group, the Nazis, was one group promoting fascism. Economically, the Nazis didn’t fit easily into the traditional right-left spectrum. Their full name was the National Socialist German Workers Party, implying a left-leaning stance, but Nazis hated communists and considered them their arch enemies along with Jews. After WWI, Hitler was an army spy who ferreted out communists. On the other hand, Nazis claimed at first to hate the crassness of capitalism and the red in their flag represented a peoples’ movement; they were populists who appealed to the masses. One complication for Hitler economically was that his special army of street thugs, the Brownshirts (or Sturmabteilung), were anti-capitalist, but industrialists like steel magnate Fritz Thyseen and Henry Ford eventually bankrolled the Nazis’ rise to power, along with gold confiscated from Jewish bankers. When that tension became irreconcilable by 1934, Hitler had left-wing factions (Strasserists) and Brownshirt leaders murdered on the Night of the Long Knives and the capitalists took control. In Italy, Mussolini described fascism as a “merger between state and corporate power.”

Hitler (far right, seated) with his army comrades of the Bavarian Reserve Infantry Regiment 16 (c. 1914–18)

Corporal Hitler with World War I Comrades of the Bavarian Reserve Infantry Regiment 16 (c. 1914–18)

Hitler had fought for Germany rather than his native Austria in WWI because of his admiration for Germany. He reinvented himself there after his rejection to art school resulted in him living as a bum on Vienna’s streets prior to the war. Corporal Hitler loved the trenches and sanctioned killing of the Great War, in which he won the Iron Cross for his dangerous work as a courier. Like some others in the military, he despised the “November criminals” who capitulated to the Allies in the armistice that ended the war. Marxists, Jews, and republicans all “stabbed Germany in the back” according to this theory – a distorted legend that underestimated the extreme pressure Germany’s military and economy were actually under by the fall of 1918. Germany gave up for a reason. Hitler interpreted his numerous escapes during WWI as a sign that God had singled him out for the divine mission of running Germany. He was convalescing from a mustard gas attack when the war ended and may have suffered a groin injury at the Battle of the Somme in 1916. He often recounted his miraculous recovery at a Berlin hospital toward the end of the war, when he regained his sight and had a vision of Jews stabbing the German eagle. As specialists in hate, there was plenty more room under the Nazi tent for others besides Jews and communists, including Gypsies (Romani), Jehovah’s Witnesses, homosexuals, and disabled, all of whom they wanted exterminated.

Stab-in-the-Back Postcard from Austria, 1919, UC-Santa Barbara

Stab-in-the-Back Postcard from Austria, 1919, UC-Santa Barbara

Hitler and a band of former generals, including Erich Ludendorff, tried but failed to take over Munich in 1923 in the Beer Hall Putsch, after which Hitler was arrested. His eloquent and passionate trial defense increased his notoriety, though. He won over a portion of the jury and, rather than being executed, he got five years in comfortable house arrest. There, he dictated Mein Kampf or, My Struggle, condemning the Versailles settlement and blaming Germany’s small Jewish population for problems in banking and their potential to bring about communism (Lenin was ¼ Jewish). Banking and communism aren’t generally grouped together for obvious reasons but, in Hitler’s mind, both were at fault. Jews did control much of Germany’s gold, but mainly because it was illegal for them to hold currency. As mentioned, Nazis confiscated much of it, using it to finance their military. Swiss banks laundered stamped Jewish bullion for the Nazis. Mein Kampf didn’t sell well at first, as Hitler was mostly forgotten in the mid-1920s, but he made it compulsory reading after he seized power in 1933 and the royalties made him rich.

Protocols of the Elder of Zion

Protocols of the Elder of Zion

Nazi interpretation of Judaism drew on The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, a forgery that described a Jewish conspiracy to dominate the world and control finance and the media while fostering religious conflict. Numerous credible papers like the London Times and New York Times investigated it at the time and declared it a complete hoax. There never was any such thing as the “Elders of Zion.” But it was the same heap of trash that Henry Ford and the KKK published half a million copies of in the U.S. and it lives on today in the Middle East among militant Muslims. While Ford was a brilliant engineer and businessman and Hitler a brilliant politician, they were both too undiscriminating as readers/thinkers to understand that Protocols was obvious malarky. It had primary sources, at least, but they were fake. How could Jews take over the world with only 1.7% of even Europe’s population and why would they want to? Protocols’ author understood that often the market for a book’s ideas trumps its validity and was playing to readers’ emotional disposition toward anti-Semitism.

Another hallmark of successful propaganda is to deflect attention by projecting one’s own agenda onto the opponent (e.g. scientists who believe in anthropogenic climate change are only motivated by profit motive). Somebody was promoting religious conflict, all right, but it wasn’t European Jews; it was Nazis. Inspired by Protocols, Nazis published a similarly inspired propagandist newspaper called the Völkischer Beobachter that served as the official voice of the party for a quarter century, from 1920-45.

Moreover, Nazis really were conspiring to dominate the world. Mein Kampf laid out a blueprint for future domination by vigorous, blonde, racially pure Aryans descended from a mythical pre-Roman race of giants. For Hitler, racial mixing had deprived the Aryans of their supernatural powers, with Jews being the primary genetic drag. Like the Elders of Zion, “Aryans” never existed as far as any serious scholar can tell. Hitler had soaked up the anti-Semitism of his native Austria more than most — according to some DNA-based accounts, perhaps struggling to cope with his own family being part-Jewish — and wanted to ethnically cleanse Germany and Europe as a whole. Nazis kept it under wraps that Hitler couldn’t meet their own standard of ethnic purity by disproving the Judaism of all four grandparents.

Guido Von List

Guido Von List

One influence on Hitler’s anti-Semitism in Vienna was occultist poet Guido Von List, a figure still revered by some neo-Nazis. Few people took notice of Mein Kampf when it was first published because few anticipated the Nazis could actually gain power. Groups like the Nazis were still marginal in the mid-1920s. After the Stock Market Crash of 1929 worsened Germany’s economy, Hitler’s message of order and violence resonated among a critical balance of those suffering from hunger and inflation and they intimidated many others. Hitler wrote in Mein Kampf, “Only the application of brute force used continuously and ruthlessly can bring about the decision in favor of the side it supports.”

After Nazis claimed victory in the disputed 1933 elections, they set about dismantling the democracy that had brought them to power. In the euphemistically titled Law to Remedy the Distress of the People, or Enabling Bill, they outlawed future elections and granted unlimited power to Chancellor Hitler, or Der Führer (leader). The Burning of the Reichstag (parliament building) was the key pretext for Nazis suspending civil liberties, eradicating communists, and suspending republicanism. They blamed a Dutch communist for the fire and beheaded him while communists and other non-Nazis (and most historians) suspected the Nazis themselves of arson in a false-flag operation. Nazis won more parliamentary elections shortly thereafter, giving them an outright majority rather than a mere plurality, but any semblance of democracy was evaporating by then. Hitler said, “There will be no mercy now. Anyone standing in the way will be cut down.” Nazis thereafter arrested and detained people without pressing charges or allowing them to stand trial and passed the Enabling Bill that, based on a perpetual “state of emergency,” transitioned Germany into a dictatorship.

Firemen Battling the Reichstag Fire, February 1933, National Archives

The Reichstag fire and response intimidated and/or brought on board many middle-class Germans who were otherwise skeptical of the new regime. Nazis ostracized republicans (i.e. Social Democrats and Center Catholic Party) as “socio-traitors” for not going along with book burnings, harassments, and heavy-handed tactics. In the Berlin suburb of Köpenick, Sturmabteilung (SA) rounded up hundreds and tortured to death 91 resistant Jews, Social Democrats, communists, and Catholics in the “Week of Bloodshed,” throwing their corpses in the river. Nazis beat prisoners until their kidneys exploded and poured hot tar in open wounds. As one German put it in 1933, “Everyday the opposition is tortured with whips and electric drills. Better to celebrate and howl with the wolves.” Those that refused to raise their hand and Heil Hitler (salute) were sent off to the camps with the others.

First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out–
Because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out–
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out–
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me–and there was no one left to speak for me.

Martin Niemöller, German Protestant Pastor

Lone Man Refusing Nazi Salute

Lone Man Refusing Nazi Salute

SwastikaNazi Ideology
Hitler’s religion, like his economics, was ambiguous and disputed to this day. He remained a Catholic until the end of his life but he privately expressed animosity toward the Church. Der Führer also criticized atheists as enemies of the state, later using that as a pretext for waging war on the USSR, and claimed in Mein Kampf that he was “doing the work of the Lord” by “defending himself against the Jew.” But there was really only room for one messiah in Nazi Germany. School children learned and recited that Hitler himself was the savior in their pledge of allegiance. Some Catholics defiantly rejected the Nazis and never cooperated. They, along with Protestants who spoke out, were sent to concentration camps with Jews. The Catholic Church as a whole, though, signed a 1933 Concordat (agreement) guaranteeing that they could regulate their own affairs in exchange for not challenging or resisting the Nazis. International Jews supported economic boycotts for awhile but, after the Haavara Agreement in 1933, Zionist organizations called off the boycotts in exchange for Nazis transferring 60k Jew immigrants and $100 million in assets to Jewish Palestine.

Nazis mined and misinterpreted the religions, philosophy, history, and science around them for their worst aspects, brewing them into their own diabolical ideology. From Christianity, they took anti-Semitism. Building on that long-standing foundation of religious anti-Judaism through their “Positive Christianity,” they displayed copies of Protestant reformer Martin Luther’s On the Lies of the Jews (1543) at their rallies. Luther’s diatribe called for their expulsion on the severest terms and reinforced negative imagery of Jews as “full of the devil’s feces…which they wallow in like swine.” Nazis hoped that Positive Christianity would transition to a new Nazi faith. Beyond spinning and subverting mainstream religion on their behalf, they added a healthy sprinkling of occult nonsense, in the tradition of Guido Von List.

German Police Tormenting Injured Jew in Poland, ca. 1939

German Police Tormenting Injured Jew in Poland, ca. 1939

Mostly, though, Nazis played on modern racial and economic anti-Semitism. They tapped into modern Gentiles’ resentment that Jews were disproportionately represented in high-profile fields like banking, journalism, entertainment, and retail ownership. Many German Jews were relative newcomers, having escaped the Russian pogroms of 1903-06, and being outsiders raised suspicions in Germany and Austria. When Hitler was a young man in Vienna, the city’s mayor Karl Lueger pandered to Gentile Austrians’ xenophobia. Jewish involvement in finance and ownership of gold, especially among high-profile wealthy families like the Rothschilds and Ephrussis, seemed to underscore their transient status as they were less tied to country through land ownership and local currency.

Vienna Mayor Karl Lueger

Hitler stressed that Jews, along with communists, were responsible for Germany’s downfall in WWI, though neither played any demonstrable role that historians can see. Nazis likened both Judaism and communism to cancerous growths that had to be eradicated from the body politic. (When German researchers discovered that smoking caused actual cancer during World War II, they kept it under wraps hoping that the popular habit would kill off people in opposing countries like Britain and the U.S.)

From philosophy, Nazis drew on a key misinterpretation of Friedrich Nietzsche; his sister reversed Friedrich’s scathing condemnation of anti-Semitism when she translated his work after his death. They also took Nietzsche’s idea of the Übermensch who rises above the common herd and its old-fashioned black-and-white notions of morality and applied it to Aryanism. Taking a cue from Guido Von List, they also modified the swastika flag symbol (upper left) from older symbols representing good luck, or well-being.

Nazi Euthanasia Propaganda Poster

Nazi Euthanasia Propaganda Poster

The woman is holding a baby and the man is holding a shield inscribed with the title of Nazi Germany's 1933 Law for the Prevention of Hereditarily Diseased Offspring (their compulsory sterilization law). The couple is in front of a map of Germany, surrounded by the flags of nations which had enacted (to the left) or were considering (bottom and to the right) similar legislation.

The woman is holding a baby and the man is holding a shield inscribed with the title of Nazi Germany’s 1933 Law for the Prevention of Hereditarily Diseased Offspring (their compulsory sterilization law). The couple is in front of a map of Germany, surrounded by the flags of nations which had enacted (to the left) or were considering (bottom and to the right) similar legislation.

From science and history, Nazis espoused a crude version of survival-of-the-fittest evolutionary theory and grafted it onto society, reducing history to a biological struggle. As was the case elsewhere, lesser minds transformed Darwin’s real science of natural selection into racist social science and back into pseudo-science. That pseudo-science was known as eugenics, the point of which (at the time, at least) was to study why everyone else in the world was inferior to blond-haired, blue-eyed Nordic Europeans and then use that science to justify ethnic cleansing.

As we saw in Chapter 4, biological racism went back centuries and predated both Darwin and the American eugenics movement. But South Africa, Sweden (Uppsala University), and the U.S. were epicenters of eugenic research and policy in the early 20th century. Sweden continued a sterilization program on its criminals and mentally ill until 1975. California eugenicists translated their works into German and circulated them among Nazi officials. One told a fellow a colleague after returning from Germany, “Everywhere I sensed that their opinions have been tremendously stimulated by American thought…I want you, dear friend, to carry this thought with you for the rest of your life, that you have really jolted into action a great government of 60 million people.” California eugenicists published Nazi literature, in turn, and arranged for an exhibit on Nazi science at the Los Angeles County Museum for the American Public Health Association’s annual meeting in August 1934. The superintendent of Virginia’s Western State Hospital worried that “the Germans are beating us at our own game.” Leon Whitney of the American Eugenics Society bemoaned that, “while we were pussy-footing around…the Germans were calling a spade a spade.” These critics might have have been underselling American impact. Harry Laughlin, the father of eugenics in the U.S., was awarded an honorary doctorate at Heidelberg University for his work on the “science of racial cleansing.” The poster on the right translates into We Are Not Alone, referring to other countries with sterilization laws. Hitler wrote admirably of America’s racist immigration policies in Mein Kampf (1924) and wrote a letter to American eugenicist Madison Grant, calling his book The Passing of the Great Race (1916) “my bible.” Historian Edwin Black has shown that the Rockefeller Foundation and the Carnegie Institution seeded eugenic research in Germany. The Rockefellers funded Josef the “Angel of Death” Mengele’s research before he moved to the Auschwitz concentration camp. American support for eugenics, both intellectual and scientific, came before Americans knew that Germans had expanded their agenda beyond sterilization and breeding programs to eugenicide, or extermination.

Acutely aware of history — as are all totalitarian movements — Nazis situated their new regime as the latest German empire, the 3rd Reich, succeeding the Holy Roman Empire and modern German empire of 1871-1918. They also embraced idealized versions of medieval chivalry and knighthood. For scholarly credentials on the geopolitical need and justification for conquering Europe, they relied on Karl Haushofer, who wrote his Ph.D. dissertation on Japanese militarism and taught future Deputy Führer Rudolph Hess at Munich University. He stressed Germany’s need to compete with Britain’s Royal Navy by dominating sea-lanes in the North Sea, Mediterranean, and Suez Canal. Haushofer met Hitler through Hess and helped convince Hitler to ally the European Axis Powers, Germany and Italy, with Japan in 1940. (The professor’s son was later involved in a plot to kill Hitler in 1944.)

As the head of the top secret police/paramilitary rung, the Shutzstaffle — or protection squad, or SS — Heinrich Himmler led what was essentially a pagan cult, replete with rituals, rings and the Wewelsburg Castle that would become the “center of the new world” after the “final victory,” similar to King Arthur’s Camelot. More so than Hitler, Himmler was brazenly anti-Christian. The only Christian element in the SS cult was its obsession with the Holy Grail, a medieval legend that connects to the Holy Chalice of Christ’s Last Supper. Yet, Nazi/SS ideology retained the basic framework of a messiah and scripture. Heil Hitler, the Nazi salute, translated not just to hail (as in “Hail Caesar”), but also heal. German citizens attracted to Nazism hoped to be healed, spiritually, from the wounds inflicted by WWI and the Depression. According to their theory, Himmler was the priest of a new, forward-thinking state religion that would expunge the “plague” of Christianity, with Hitler as the new messiah and Mein Kampf as the holy book. An academic unit at Wewelsburg called the Ahnenerbe challenged traditional universities, whose denial of the Aryan’s existence was supposedly warped by Jewish influence. They interpreted runestones and traveled as far as the Tibetan Himalayas to find “evidence” of Aryan history. Himmler was the main architect of the Final Solution, or what Hitler called “the final solution to the Jewish question:” extermination.

Ferdinand Porsche

Ferdinand Porsche

Rebuilding Germany
Politically, Nazis despised the disorganized ineptitude of democracies, with their respect for debate and free speech. Fascists could claim that their dictatorships got things done, most famously expressed in the phrase trains ran on time. Hitler implemented a more aggressive Keynesian strategy of stimulus spending than his contemporary Franklin Roosevelt, rebuilding the country and putting people back to work. Relative to GDP, Germany spent about 5x more than the New Dealers, and it worked. The Nazis pioneered interstate engineering (four-lane roads, on-ramps/exits, overpasses) in their Autobahn, that they hoped could move their military around the country more efficiently than dirt roads had during WWI. The project actually began under the Weimar Republic but had floundered.

Hitler not only admired Henry Ford’s anti-Semitism, but also the industrial efficiency of his plants, and hoped to jumpstart Germany’s economy with their own car for the common folk, the Volkswagen. Hitler suggested the aerodynamic “beetle” shape to its designer, Ferdinand Porsche, who shared the dream of a car for the people. They invited Ford to Germany and awarded the industrialist the Grand Cross of the German Eagle on his 75th birthday.

German Family Enjoying Beetle & Radio in Rebuilt Economy

German Family Enjoying Beetle & Radio in Rebuilt Economy

Nazis reveled in the country’s economic rebound and patriotic resurgence. They excelled at pageantry, hosting orchestrated public festivals where Germans camped out and celebrated their culture. In huge stadiums, they heard inspiring speeches and showed their allegiance in choreographed and well-documented spectacles. Hugo Boss designed sharp uniforms for the SS and Hitler Youth. Nazis indoctrinated youth and Hitler said that he hoped to see, again, in their eyes “the gleam of the beast of prey.” Hitler Youth and Brownshirts marched to songs adapted from Harvard’s fight song, written by Hitler’s friend and Harvard alum Ernst Hanfstaengl (right). They held Nazi Party Rallies in Nuremberg (Nürnberg) from 1923-1938. Hitler loved film and was at least as adept on the radio as FDR. He took acting lessons and began to excel after the invention of sound film. He studied dramatic gestures in opera and cultivated a domineering persona to better manipulate the masses, of which he said, “they’re feminine and stupid…only emotion and hatred can keep them under control.” Charlie Chaplin called Hitler the best actor he’d ever seen.

The Totenehrung (honoring of the fallen) at the 1934 Nuremberg Rally. SS leader Heinrich Himmler, Adolf Hitler and SA leader Viktor Lutze (from L to R) on the stone terrace in front of the Ehrenhalle (Hall of Honor) in the Luitpoldarena. In the background is the crescent-shaped Ehrentribüne (the Tribune of Honor).

The Totenehrung (honoring of the fallen) at the 1934 Nuremberg Rally. SS leader Heinrich Himmler, Adolf Hitler and SA leader Viktor Lutze (from L to R) on the stone terrace in front of the Ehrenhalle (Hall of Honor) in the Luitpoldarena. In the background is the crescent-shaped Ehrentribüne (the Tribune of Honor).

Germany started a breeding program between single women and Nazi officers called Lebensborn to propagate their new super race. Their political agenda started off innocuously in comparison with what came later: instituting prayer in public schools, loosening up gun laws (except for Jews), banning homosexuality, revoking Jewish citizenship and banning intermarriage between Jews and Gentiles with the Nuremberg Laws. German Jews were now Jews in Germany, but not Germans.

The first concentration camps opened in 1933 but were mostly kept under wraps. Nazis were thuggish relative to most governments but stayed within the mainstream enough to curry cautious acceptance among fellow Europeans. Jews seemed no worse off legally than minorities in many countries as long as one didn’t know about the camps. Winston Churchill of Great Britain, for instance, appreciated Nazis as a bulwark against Soviet communism; and they were preventing the sort of Bolshevik revolution that happened in Russia in 1917. When the German Hindenburg airship blew up docking in New Jersey in 1937, Franklin Roosevelt sent Hitler a condolence note from his fishing boat off the Texas coast. Nazis salvaged their reputation by curbing inflation and turning around the German economy.

1936 Berlin Olympics
They showcased their rebuilt country in the 1936 Olympics. The mere fact that Berlin was chosen for the games signaled Germany’s readmission into the international community and a tacit approval of fascism. It was a coming-out party, of sorts. Nazis took full advantage by building the first substantial Olympic village, temporarily taking down anti-Semitic billboards, clearing Gypsies (Romani) out of the city, outlawing prostitution, and treating foreign journalists and athletes hospitably. Visitors were oblivious to construction of the Sachsenhausen concentration camp north of the city. The sports complex was magnificent by 1930s standards and the same Hindenburg balloon that crashed in New Jersey a year later flew over the main stadium during opening ceremonies. Nazis underscored their connection with the ancient Greek inventors of the Olympics by relaying the torch from Athens to Berlin — a tradition that lives on. In fact, some members of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) thought Germany was a good choice to host the games because of their embrace of eugenics, similar to the ancient Greek Spartans’ killing of deformed babies.Bundesarchiv-TorchRelay1936BerlinGames

Sommerolympiade, Siegerehrung Weitsprung

Jesse Owens On Medal Stand, Berlin 1936, Bundesarchiv

Poster for Leni Riefenstahl's Triumph of the Will (1934)

Hitler hoped to use the Olympics to prove the superiority of fascist regimes and largely succeeded. Germany, Italy and Japan did well — Germany finished first in the overall medal count and the U.S. second — and American Olympic Committee president Avery Brundage argued that the U.S. should consider that as a lesson on the upside of fascism (shortly after those comments, and likely because of them, Brundage became president of the IOC). But fascists didn’t win every event; African-American Jesse Owens (left) famously humiliated Hitler by winning four gold medals in track & field. The record-breaking sprinter from Ohio St. upset Hitler’s notion of Aryan superiority in front of a packed house and early television cameras.

The Olympics bought Hitler time and helped camouflage the Nazis’ real intentions, though the IOC awarded Germany the Winter Olympics in 1940 even after news of the Holocaust had leaked out (the Games were eventually canceled). Documentarian Leni Riefenstahl chronicled the 1936 Olympics and the 1934 Nuremberg Rally in Triumph of the Will. These aesthetically sophisticated films are must-sees for any student interested in propaganda or how the Nazis won over Germans in the 1930s. Riefenstahl is considered one of the greatest filmmakers of the 20th century despite her friendship with Hitler.

Alsace-Lorraine Region with Rhineland in Yellow

Alsace-Lorraine Region (in Yellow) That Prussia Took From France in 1871

Expansion
The Versailles agreement barred Germany from maintaining anything but a skeletal defense, and most European powers, including Germany, pledged peace and promises of arbitration in disputes to one another in the Locarno Treaties of 1925. But France and the USSR signed a mutual pact in 1935 (similar to 1892), outraging Germany, and Germany was openly violating terms of the Versailles and Locarno treaties by the mid-1930s. Their economic revival wasn’t just based on highways, but also munitions. They made their first expansionary move in March 1936, retaking the Rhineland region ceded to France after WWI. That included the industrially important Ruhr Valley (the Ruhr is a tributary of the Rhine).

Rhineland Invasion, 1936

Rhineland Invasion, 1936

Hitler actually instructed his troops to turn back if the French challenged them, but no such opposition materialized. Portions of the region like the Saarland voted to rejoin Germany, despite the fact that the French-held areas were refugees for opponents of the Nazis. France was surprised at the outcome of the Saarland vote. Germany claimed the Rhineland takeover was a justified response to the treaty France signed with the USSR, and the Versailles Treaty indeed called for a referendum there after fifteen years.

Sudetenland

Czech districts with an ethnic German population in 1934 of 25% or more (pink), 50% or more (red), and 75 % or more (dark red) in 1935

Their next moves were the German-speaking Sudetenland of Czechoslovakia, a country created from scratch at Versailles, then on to Hitler’s home country, where Austrian Nazis helped expedite a mostly bloodless takeover called the Anschluss. The Nazis had sympathizers and collaborators in virtually every European country. For those that opposed him, Hitler took advantage of their desire for peace, knowing that he could get away with more than he would have had they not been haunted by WWI. And he took advantage of the widespread hatred of Jews throughout the Western world. Later, when the war broke out, only the Danish (among occupied countries) refused to cooperate with their arrest, instead smuggling Jews in fishing boats to neutral Sweden.

Like every country on the make, Germany was only “defending itself” and its acquisition or reacquisition of German-speaking territory gave that narrative a shred of truth early on. The word for Germany’s army, the Wehrmacht, translates to defense force.

Yellow BadgeAnti-Semitism Worsens
The German Jewish population only slowly lost faith in the idea that Germans and Western Europeans were too sophisticated and progressive to go for the type of rampant anti-Semitism more associated with Eastern Europe. Aside from being de-emancipated by the Nuremberg Laws, they were forced to wear yellow Star of Davids. On Kristallnacht, the “night of the broken glass” in 1938, Hitler’s paramilitary troops pillaged Jewish businesses and synagogues throughout Germany and Austria, killing hundreds as they rounded up 30k Jews to be sent off to concentration camps. They blamed Jews for the damage since they’d been the targets and required that all the insurance money go to the state. The pretext for the attacks was the assassination of a German official in Paris by a Jewish teenager from Poland. FDR ordered American Ambassador Hugh Wilson home after the Kristallnacht. Wilson supported Hitler and broke with his predecessor William Dodd’s (1933-37) policy by attending a Nuremberg Rally. Wilson complained that “Jewish-controlled” critics back home sang “hymns of hate while efforts are made over here to build a better future.”

The German Weapons Act of 1938 loosened up gun restrictions, deregulating rifles and shotguns altogether for Gentiles while banning Jewish ownership, manufacture or dealing of firearms. Modern American gun enthusiasts anxious to liken registration to Nazism have their history mostly backward. While it would still be an irrelevant and bad analogy, a better comparison would be to liken gun control advocates to the Weimar Republic, since they toughened gun laws from 1919-32 in an effort to tame the sort of paramilitary groups Hitler led. Those were the laws the Nazis repealed in time for Gentiles to use guns on Jews during the Kristallnacht. Previously the Nazis tightened up registration laws for social democrats, another potential enemy they didn’t want armed. What’s not backward about modern gun enthusiasts’ interpretation is that the Nazis took advantage of gun registrations to confiscate Jewish guns, though it’s worth pointing out that in the vast majority of historical cases registration hasn’t led to confiscation. However, having guns wouldn’t have helped Jews much as they were extremely outnumbered.

Many Jews migrated when they could up through 1938 when immigration quotas even went unfilled. However, Western countries tightened their immigration restrictions once the going got rough. Some Jews had escaped to England earlier and later aided the Allies in translating bugged conversations of German POWs. In the U.S., Jewish refugee Albert Einstein helped convince FDR to develop the atomic bomb. But by 1938, Jews could still leave Germany with an exit tax, and no one would take them — at least not in large numbers. Polls showed that most Americans disapproved of Nazi policies, but less than 20% of the “Greatest Generation” favored opening American shores to Jewish immigrants. Eighty-Five percent of Protestants and Catholics opposed offering Jews refuge, as did 25% of American Jews. We should remember, at least, that few people knew of the concentration camps in the late 1930s.

Baron Georg von Trapp

Baron Georg von Trapp

It wasn’t easy for Gentiles (non-Jews) to enter the country for that matter since authorities feared Nazi sympathizers coming to spy or cause damage as Germans had during WWI. The family of Captain Georg Johannes (Baron) Von Trapp — subject of The Sound of Music (1964) — was detained at Ellis Island and nearly deported back to Europe, where they probably would’ve been arrested and liquidated by the Nazis. An Austrian naval commander decorated for service at the Boxer Rebellion and in WWI, Baron von Trapp refused to fly the Swastika at their estate and then refused an invitation for his family to sing at Hitler’s birthday party. They fled Europe and headed for America with traveler’s visas (their 2nd trip there), but his wife Maria accidentally told the customs agent that they hoped to stay. Luckily, a family friend vouched for them and the Trapp Family Singers settled in Vermont and began touring the country.

Fictional Baron von Trapp, Played By Christopher Plummer In Sound of Music (1964), Tumblr

Fictional Baron von Trapp, Played By Christopher Plummer In Sound of Music (1964), Tumblr

Jewish Refugees Aboard the SS St. Louis Look Out Through the Portholes While Docked in Havana

Jewish Refugees Aboard the SS St. Louis Look Out Through the Portholes While Docked in Havana

Most Jewish immigrants were less fortunate. Defying First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt’s wishes, Franklin refused to loosen immigration laws once large numbers of refugees tried to escape in the late 1930s. The U.S. and Cuba turned away the MS St. Louis with nearly 1k Jewish refugees on board in 1939 and Britain was no friendlier. Allowing the passengers entry into the U.S. would’ve violated the immigration quotas set in the 1920s. The U.S. allowed a total of ~ 211k Jewish immigrants from 1939-46.

The Nazis couldn’t help but relish the harshness of Anglo-American immigration policy. One German diplomat gloated, “Since in many countries it was recently regarded as wholly incomprehensible why Germany did not want to preserve in its population an element like the Jews…it appears outstanding that countries seem in no way anxious to make use of those elements themselves now that the opportunity offers.” The tightening up of foreign borders in the late 30’s helped seal the fate of Jews trapped in Europe. Cartoonist Theodor Geisel, aka Dr. Seuss, captured the prevailing sentiment of most Americans regarding refugees circa 1941:
Fascism
& the Axis Powers
Liberalism (broadly defined) was declining in Europe by the 1930s as republics struggled to establish order amidst the post-WWI chaos. Spanish fascists under Francisco Franco won their Civil War over Loyalist Republicans (and 3k American volunteers in the Abraham Lincoln Brigade) and an alliance of fascists and Catholics won a short skirmish over social democrats in Austria in 1934 (the Februarkämpfe), setting that German-speaking country up for an easy annexation by Nazis in the 1938 Anschluss.

Fascist Benito Mussolini took over Italy in 1922. In Africa, Italy controlled Libya and Somalia and, in 1935, they bombed Ethiopians armed with spears into submission. Their aerial blitz, along with similar civilian attacks by Spanish fascists, anticipated larger attacks in WWII (the Germans bombed Paris and London some toward the very end of WWI). Nazis didn’t establish a formal alliance with Franco’s Spanish fascists but allowed them to use their civilians to test out German aerial bombs.

Italian Dictator Benito Mussolini Marching w. Hitler

Italian Dictator Benito Mussolini Marching w. Hitler

Mussolini was one of Hitler’s inspirations around the time he wrote Mein Kampf. The Heil Hitler right-hand salute the Nazis made famous started with Mussolini, who argued that handshakes were too effeminate. Americans used a similar salute for the Pledge of Allegiance after its invention in 1892 but switched to the hand over the heart during WWII. Just as Hitler was proud of the fascists’ performance in the 1936 Olympics (except against Jesse Owens), Mussolini crowed about Italy’s back-to-back wins in the 1934 and ’38 soccer World Cup. He dreamt of reviving the glory of the old Roman Empire (really, the Heil salute started with Caesar, as in “Hail Caesar”). While Mussolini shared Hitler’s love of violence and recruited paramilitary Blackshirts who could win street battles, he wasn’t anti-Semitic. His own mistress was Jewish, and Jews even gained equality under Italian fascism. Mussolini had been a communist when he was younger — even gaining the positive admiration of Lenin — but, like Hitler, he grew to despise communists and blamed them for Italy’s weakness during the Great War. Mussolini also temporarily stamped out the Mafia’s influence in Sicily and throughout Italy. Unfortunately, for the U.S., that led to emigration and the sudden influx of new gangsters kickstarted a re-jostling in New York called the Castellammarese War. When the dust settled, the modern American Mafia was born, led by Lucky Luciano and the “Commission” of Five Families.

Cheb, Anschluss of the Sudetenland, October 1938, German Federal Archive

Cheb, Anschluss of the Sudetenland, October 1938, German Federal Archive

Back in Europe Hitler established an alliance with Il Duce (Mussolini) as Germany and Italy formed the Axis Powers, so named because the two countries formed an axis running north to south in central Europe. After Japan’s invasion of Manchuria and Italy’s conquering of Ethiopia, Hitler realized how impotent the international community (i.e. League of Nations) would be in the face of naked aggression. Germany’s Rhineland, Austrian and Czechoslovakian (Sudetenland) invasions came on their heels.

Munich Pact
After the Austrian invasion, the Allies met with Der Führer (Hitler) in Munich. In the 1938 Munich Pact, Hitler agreed to not expand any further beyond what he’d already taken, including the portion of German-speaking Czechoslovakia called the Sudetenland, but the Allies got nothing in return other than temporary peace and that empty promise. Hitler invaded the rest of Czechoslovakia five months later and Poland and France within two years. As American Ambassador to the United Kingdom’s Court of St. James, Joseph Kennedy, Sr. represented the U.S. by proxy at Munich, while Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain represented Great Britain and Édouard Daladier France. Winston Churchill, who was out of power in Britain, Soviet leader Joseph Stalin and America’s Soviet Ambassador Joseph Davies all wanted to unite against Hitler in a collective security pact, but that didn’t happen. For his part, Hitler failed to form a hoped-for alliance with Britain. FDR was skeptical off the record but cabled “good man” to Chamberlain after the Allies signed the Munich Pact with Hitler.

Neville Chamberlain & Hitler @ Berghof, September 1938

Neville Chamberlain & Hitler, September 1938

Remember Munich has become a catchphrase among Hawks in almost any circumstance since, meaning that problems are better nipped in the bud early on before they get out of control later (its other meaning is to remember the eleven Israeli athletes killed by terrorists in the 1972 Munich Olympics). The much reviled Munich Pact is often either the reason for war or at least the reason provided to the public to justify war if there are other reasons. Inaction or delay is inevitably equated with spinelessness or naiveté. This Lesson of Munich — i.e. that appeasement only feeds the appetite of the aggressor — is worth knowing for sure but has also narrowed American options ever since in areas like Vietnam and Iraq, leading to predictable, knee-jerk, escalate-first-and-ask-questions-later policies. Countries that never dither are easy to bait, for one thing, allowing enemies to dictate when, where, and how they employ resources. The smartest policy is always to keep a range of options on the table, including diplomacy, delayed action, or swift action (e.g. the Confederacy should’ve invaded Washington, D.C. early in 1861, before it was defended). Churchill himself reminded readers that all historical contexts are different. Oversimplified historical analogies can be worse than historical amnesia.

In this case, even our idea that Munich was a mistake in the first place isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. Readers familiar with WWII history might gasp or faint initially upon reading this, but permit me to explain. None of the Allies had large armies in 1938 and they weren’t prepared for war. If they’d challenged Hitler then, they might have lost the war and been worse off in the long run. The U.S. military, for instance, was about the same size as Sweden’s (330k), 17th biggest in the world, and had fewer than 500 machine guns. The British could’ve mustered two ill-equipped divisions for a continental invasion. Because of changes in their constitutional status, UK Commonwealth countries Canada, Australia, and New Zealand wouldn’t have necessarily fallen in behind Britain (England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland) if they declared war, the way they had in World War I. The British also lacked faith in the French military because of so much turnover among their political leaders; Third Republic governments averaged nine-month tenures in the 1930s. Moreover, despite what Stalin was communicating, the British still envisioned the Soviet Union as enemies not potential allies against Hitler. The British public wasn’t particularly riled up about Germany taking over German-speaking areas like the Rhineland or Austria, let alone part of newly-created Czechoslovakia (1919). Was it their job to go save people who, for all they knew, didn’t want to be saved? Austria hadn’t put up a fight anyway and the Rhineland voted to return to Germany. The Munich Pact also delayed Germany’s attack on the rest of Czechoslovakia, which Hitler later regretted. We know from archives opened in the 1950s that British military brass told Chamberlain point-blank there was no hope of defending Czechoslovakia, but that their prospects for winning a long, protracted war were decent if they had time to build planes and ships. What sort of political ruler would have sent in troops immediately based on that advice?

The Allies’ real mistake was not making better use of the time they bought at Munich so that they’d be better prepared later. Ambassador Kennedy’s son John argued just that in his senior thesis at Harvard, later published as Why England Slept, an allusion to Churchill’s While England Slept. When Germany attacked in 1940, France was no stronger than they were two years earlier and Britain was only slowly strengthening, its main gains coming in the Royal Air Force (RAF). In Britain’s case, it was wiser for them to prepare more at home than to take a futile stand in a small German-speaking part of Czechoslovakia tucked on the other side of Germany. That’s slowly but surely what they did and the RAF’s fighter technology was further along in 1940 then ’38.

Europe in 1923

Europe in 1923 w. Sudetenland Circled, George Washington Bacon, Library of Congress’ Map & Geography Division

Germans in Western Austro-Hungarian Empire, ca. 1911

Ethnic distribution in Austria-Hungary in 1911: regions with a German majority are depicted in pink, those with Czech majorities in blue

Critics later derided Neville Chamberlain for his broken promise of “peace in our time” and Winston Churchill capitalized by returning to power as Britain’s Prime Minister. But Churchill’s argument that Britain missed its chance to stymie Hitler at Munich was unrealistic, at least minus the aforementioned three-way pact with the Americans and Soviets that he favored along with Davies and Stalin. Not only were British and French citizens desperate to avoid another war — and so far, they hadn’t been directly attacked — but Churchill himself wasn’t willing to open a western front once the war began!  Should Chamberlain have been expected to open an eastern front even earlier or a western front to draw German forces from Czechoslovakia?

Not everyone agrees that the Western Allies were less prepared in relation to Germany in 1938 than they were in 1939 or ’40. Hitler’s own generals argued at the Nuremberg Trials after the war that the Allies missed a chance to defeat Germany as late as 1938, pointing out that bad intelligence caused the Allies to overestimate the strength of German forces at the time. They’d supposedly tricked American spies and visitors into overestimating the size of their Luftwaffe, or air force. Some historians think likewise, arguing that Germany would’ve been easier to defeat in 1938 than after 1939. British military intelligence tended to overestimate German strength prior to Munich and underestimate it after, according to this line of thinking. Also, Germany occupied far more territory by 1940, including northern Europe, Poland, southeastern Europe, and North Africa, presumably making them harder to reign in (though their resources were spread thinner, partly offsetting this factor).

The classic appeasement-was-a-mistake interpretation of Munich isn’t necessarily wrong, but it needs to be predicated on this angle: that the Allies were stronger in relation to Germany proportionally in 1938 than they were by 1939-40. Without that critical premise, the argument falls apart and, moreover, the Free World should be grateful that the maligned Chamberlain was in power rather than the revered Churchill. Churchill himself allowed for the advantages of buying time in his Second World War (1948-1953), writing that, as of 1938:

“No one could deny that we were hideously unprepared for war. Who had been more forward in the proving this than I and my friends? Great Britain had allowed herself to be far surpassed by the strength of the German Air Force. All of our vulnerable points were unprotected…If Hitler was honest and a lasting peace had in fact been achieved, Chamberlain was right. If, unhappily, he had been deceived, at least we should gain a breathing space to repair the worst of our neglects.”

Why, then, was Churchill of the opinion that Munich was a mistake, both as it was unfolding and in retrospect? Because, while the extra time aided Britain, allowing for development of the Hurricane and Spitfire planes that defeated the Luftwaffe in the Battle of Britain two years later, the French army was stronger in relation to Germany in 1938 than they were two years later, and Germany was able to recruit even more soldiers from the areas it conquered after 1938.

Churchill’s calculations aside, the Munich Pact’s more simplified teleological critique is a classic case of “armchair quarterbacking” as American sports fans say, or criticizing only with the benefit of hindsight or being out of power. As for Ambassador Kennedy, who was also anti-Semitic, he clung too long to his German appeasement policy, ruining his presidential hopes with pessimistic comments about democracy’s future (or lack thereof). Meanwhile, his son John got around a medical disqualification and went on to command a PT (patrol torpedo) boat in the Pacific, bolstering his future political opportunities.

German Aggressions Prior to Polish Invasion, 1936- 1939, University of Texas Libraries

Absent any collective security with the Western Allies, Stalin worried that his army wasn’t strong enough to take on Hitler by himself. Germany signed a truce with the USSR whereby the countries agreed to not fight on an eastern front in any future war and to divvy up Poland, the country that lay between them. With the Nazi-Soviet Pact of 1939, Hitler was just stalling, giving his military time to catch its breath and grow stronger after taking Czechoslovakia and Austria. After a failed attempt to conquer Britain, he broke the truce and invaded the Soviet Union (USSR) in 1941 with Operation Barbarossa. Hitler hoped to divide the USSR and acquire the oil fields of the Caucasus, in the southern part of the country. Seizing the oil would not only fuel the Third Reich but also paralyze the Soviet Red Army.

The Western Allies never forgot Stalin’s willingness in 1939 to deflect German military aggression in their direction. Of course, Stalin could argue that the Western Allies had tried to do the same to him at Munich in 1938. Either way, when Hitler invaded the USSR in 1941, the Allies were slow to come to Stalin’s aid. By then they’d felt Germany’s wrath across Europe, from Poland to France, the Low Countries, Scandinavia, Greece, and Britain.

Execution of Poles by German Troops, 1939

Execution of Poles by German Troops, Leszno, October 1939

World War II In Europe
Germany’s Blitzkrieg (lightning warfare) invasion of Poland in September 1939 started World War II in Europe. In his Obersalzberg Speech on the eve of the battle, Hitler laid out his ruthless ambition to expand German territory:

Our strength consists in our speed and in our brutality. Genghis Khan led millions of women and children to slaughter—with premeditation and a happy heart. History sees in him solely the founder of a state. It’s a matter of indifference to me what a weak western European civilization will say about me. I have issued the command—and I’ll have anybody who utters but one word of criticism executed by a firing squad—that our war aim does not consist in reaching certain lines, but in the physical destruction of the enemy. Accordingly, I have placed my death-head formation in readiness—for the present only in the East—with orders to them to send to death mercilessly and without compassion, men, women, and children of Polish derivation and language. Only thus shall we gain the living space (Lebensraum) which we need. Who, after all, speaks to-day of the annihilation of the Armenians?

"A starving child lying in a ghetto street," Warsaw Poland, by Heinz Joest, a Wehrmacht Sergeant, Yad Vashem Holocaust Memorial Museum, Israel

“A starving child lying in a ghetto street,” Warsaw Poland, by Heinz Joest, a Wehrmacht Sergeant, Yad Vashem Holocaust Memorial Museum, Israel

Italian dictator Benito Mussolini made similar comments in the Political & Social Doctrine of Fascism (1932). For Mussolini, peace was “born of the renunciation of the struggle and an act of cowardice in the face of sacrifice.” Two of the countries Germany invaded, Poland and Czechoslovakia, weren’t countries until the new map drawn up at Versailles in 1919, probably making them less resilient to attack. The Jewish child on the left is in the Warsaw Ghetto, where Germans rounded up almost the entire population and sent them to camps. After Poland’s invasion, France and Britain — still under the leadership of Neville Chamberlain — declared war on Germany, and Hitler turned his attention west after resting and rebuilding his forces during the Sitzkrieg. British called the Sitzkrieg the “Bore War,” while American journalists dubbed it the “Phony War.” Germany conquered Denmark, Norway, and the Netherlands in April and May of 1940. British-led coalition forces under First Lord of the Admiralty Winston Churchill tried to stem the Norwegian invasion but failed, lowering Brits’ confidence in Chamberlain and leading to the ascension, ironically, of Churchill as the new Prime Minister. 

The Axis Powers of Germany and Italy signed the Tripartite Pact with their imperial counterpart Japan in September 1940. Germany and Japan reinforced each other because Japan coveted the European-held colonies of Asia. Germany kept Britain, France, and the Netherlands at bay in Europe, making it impossible for them to defend their territories in British Hong Kong and Singapore, French Indochina (Vietnam), and the Dutch East Indies (Indonesia).

Animated Map or European War, 1939-45

Animated Map or European War, 1939-45

When Germany revved its war engine again, they had an easier time invading France than they had in 1914. The French built a series of bunkers along their shared border called the Maginot Line but didn’t anticipate that German tanks would daringly go through forested areas. Since this took longer, drivers fueled themselves with a methamphetamine (stimulant) called Pervitin, 35 million tablets to be precise according to researcher Norman Ohler. Germany mainly went through neutral Belgium as in 1914, through the less defended Ardennes Forest, but this time they were better able to rout French and British forces in northwest France. The Netherlands fell around the same time, in May 1940.

Allied forces from Britain, Belgium, Australia, and Canada fought with the French on the continent but had to be rescued from Dunkirk on the Belgian coast. Anticipating the upcoming Battle of Britain and seemingly willing to cut his losses with most of the 350k trapped troops, Winston Churchill refused to expose too many Royal Navy ships to U-boat attacks to rescue them. It was left to a spontaneous and patriotic armada of pleasure, merchant, and fishing boats to save those clinging to life on the coast as they and a handful of Royal Air Force (RAF) pilots above fought off the Germans. Though demoralizing at the time, preserving ships and most British forces was a key to future success because they “lived to fight another day,” as the saying goes. The famous retreat is the subject of director Christopher Nolan’s nail-biter Dunkirk (2017). Nolan’s movie inadvertently whitewashes the affair by excluding the many Africans and South Asians in the British and French armies and British merchant fleet.

British Forces Fend Off German Strafers @ the Battle of Dunkirk in June 1940, Australian War Memorial Database

French forces fought hard for a while, but France’s conservative government failed to anticipate a Nazi attack because they thought they had a good relationship with Hitler, and the army was unable to pull their act together in time despite having more tanks and artillery than Germany. Within a matter of months, outnumbered, outgunned Nazis controlled two-thirds of France, setting up a collaborative government in the town of Vichy. Free French forces left the country to fight another day, while uncooperative citizens formed an underground resistance to pester Nazis as best they could through car bombings, assassinations, etc.

Noor Inayat Khan

Noor Inayat Khan

British Special Operations Executives infiltrated France with spies to help the French Resistance. Espionage became an important part of the war effort, and the SOE often used unlikely agents as spies because they were less visible and likely to attract attention. One of their most important radio operators working behind German lines in France, for instance, was Noor Inayat Khan, daughter of a Parisian Sufi instructor. She won the George Cross, the highest civilian wartime honor in the United Kingdom. The average life expectancy of radio operators behind enemy lines was six weeks and Khan died at Dachau concentration camp after relaying important messages for two years, refusing to relinquish details about her network even when tortured by interrogators. American-born jazz singer Josephine Baker was another unlikely spy working in Vichy France. She relayed information in invisible ink on her sheet music and her profession offered a convenient cover for moving around the country. Their stories are just two of thousands that contributed to the Allies’ ultimate victory.

The United Kingdom’s new Prime Minister, Winston Churchill couldn’t convince the French to destroy their navy as they retreated and he didn’t want it to end up in German hands. Thus in July 1940, Britain destroyed the French fleet and harbor at Mers-el-Kébir in Operation Catapult — an operation about half as large and deadly as the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941. The attack helped win over FDR, who was impressed with Churchill’s ruthlessness.

With Germany occupying most of France, the Low Countries, Scandinavia, and southeastern Europe after the Battle of Greece in April 1941, they now controlled nearly the entire continent. They reached an accord with Franco’s fascist regime in Spain, but not a formal alliance like they had with Italy. Swiss banks agreed to help finance the Reich in exchange for maintaining Switzerland’s traditional neutrality. Britain stood virtually alone as they fended off Hermann Göring’s Luftwaffe in the summer and fall of 1940.

Aircraft Spotter in London, St. Paul's Cathedral in the Background, 1940, National Archives

Aircraft Spotter in London, St. Paul’s Cathedral in the Background, 1940, National Archives

Battle of Britain
In the Battle of Britain, the Luftwaffe bombed English ports, airfields, and infrastructure from June through October 1940. The bombings were supposed to set the stage for a land invasion called Operation Sea Lion. This was not a purely aerial war, as it was fought on land and sea, too, and Britain’s Royal Navy was superior to the German Kriegsmarine. German U-Boats were feared for good reason, but they didn’t have enough at the time to choke off Britain, and small English fishing boats — the same ones used to rescue soldiers at Dunkirk — mounted guns and served as minesweepers and eyes and ears.

German Messerschmitt Me 109E-4/Trop Off North African Coast, 1941, Australian War Memorial Database

Messerschmitt Me 109E-4/Trop Off North African Coast, 1941, Australian War Memorial Database

British & German Condensation Trail After Dogfight, Photo by (Mr. Putnam) Imperial War Museum

British & German Condensation Trail After Dogfight, Photo by (Mr. Putnam) Imperial War Museum

In the air, the Royal Air Force (RAF) stood as the last line of defense for the Free World. Two planes key for Britain’s survival were Hawker Hurricane and Spitfire fighters. On the face of it, these planes were inferior to the German Bf Messerschmitt 109’s they encountered in dogfights over the English Channel and countryside. The “Me 109’s” could fire superior 20mm cannon shells for a continuous minute and had aerodynamic “high-lift” slats on their wings. Also, British carbureted engines stalled in free-fall, whereas the Messerschmitts’ fuel-injected inverted V-12’s allowed them to out-maneuver, getting above or behind Spitfires and Hurricanes to fire (RAF pilots feared the “Hun in the Sun”). However, the British proved their superiority in manufacturing quantity. German engineering set the pace, but they valued quality over quantity whereas the RAF ramped up production, replacing their planes. American and British factories made weapons ’round the clock in three shifts, seven days a week, whereas German plants, with their able-bodied population spread thin and slaves on many assembly lines, ran one eight-hour shift on weekdays.

Moreover, Spitfires were the fastest planes in Europe at the time, with their Rolls-Royce engines stronger than the Messerschmitts that had to slow down to escort Stuka dive-bombers, mitigating their advantage in terms of maneuverability (a misguided order from Commander Göring). Germans also had to concern themselves with running out of gas, unlike their RAF counterparts who didn’t have to fly home across the English Channel. They only had ten minutes of combat to spare over England or risk ditching at sea. German pilot diaries written from their base in northern France indicate these trips back and forth grew wearisome and they feared going to their graves in the bottom of the Channel.

German Barges In Boulogne, France Awaiting The Invasion Of England, 1940

German Barges In Boulogne, France Awaiting The Invasion Of England, 1940, RAF Photo

The Luftwaffe never eliminated enough British planes on the ground the way they had in short order against Poland in 1939. The RAF posed more of a challenge than Germany planned for and, without air superiority, there was no hope of a land invasion. The Brits flew pilots from other occupied countries along with their own, including Poland, Czechoslovakia, the U.S. (Eagle Squadrons), and Free France, along with United Kingdom airmen from Canada, New Zealand, South Africa, and Ireland. Polish pilots were renowned for their skill and close-range dogfighting style.

English Plotting Table During Blitz

English Plotting Table @ RAF Headquarters In Uxbridge

Chain of English Radar Stations During Blitz

Chain of English Radar Stations During Blitz

The RAF’s rudimentary but robust communication network, manned by men and women of all ages, repaired itself quickly. Like the Internet, breaking any one link couldn’t sever the network of Fighter Command radar stations, plotting tables, and amateur observer posts. It was called the Dowding System after its organizer, Commander “Stuffy” Dowding. The Germans underestimated their capacity to damage the radar stations because they mistakenly thought most of them were underground. Moreover, the British learned to jam the German pilots’ navigation systems.

German Bombing of London, 1940

German Bombing of London, 1940

Dogfights in the Battle of Britain overlapped with civilian attacks on England’s industrial cities known as the “Blitz.” Citizens scurried into subways and shelters during the bombing raids, re-emerging the next morning to put out fires and care for the dead and wounded (color slide show). The British had a horrifying, if brief, preview in World War I, when giant German Zeppelins hovered over London dropping incendiary bombs, but they thwarted those attacks by blowing up the helium balloons. German bombers also attacked London in 1918, killing ~1400 people. Londoners were primed for more attacks, with science fiction writer H.G. Wells’ The Shape of Things to Come (1933, film 1936) depicting cities being laid to waste in a future war from aerial bombardment. Unlike Paris or Berlin, London had a vulnerable approach from the English Channel by enemy pilots who merely had to follow the Thames River a few miles inland.

London Daytime Bombing, September 1940

The WWII Blitz killed far more civilians than the WWI bombings. Forty-thousand “direct hit” citizens died and another 45k were injured among the “near misses” who survived. However, psychologists discovered that “remote misses” (nearby people who didn’t get hit) were only emboldened and invigorated in their fight against Germany, even less likely to give up than if they’d never experienced the bombardment. Churchill said that “nothing was so exhilarating as being shot at without result.” According to one theory, the original German plan was strategic infrastructure bombing only, but one pilot accidentally dropped his payload on citizens in London. Churchill retaliated by bombing Berlin, leading to the harsher Blitz against Britain. Hitler lost his temper and had Göring put too much focus on the civilian attacks, losing momentum in their campaign to destroy airfields and ports.

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill Flashing V for Victory Sign @ Downing Street

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill Flashing V for Victory Sign @ Downing Street

Brits also got moral support over the airwaves. Children’s fantasy writer and English professor C.S. Lewis broadcast a series of Christian apologetics later compiled in Mere Christianity (1952) — still widely read in theology seminars and Sunday schools. King George VI and Prime Minister Winston Churchill rallied the country politically. George VI, father of Elizabeth II, struggled to overcome his stutter well enough to speak on the radio, as dramatized in The King’s Speech (2010). While Churchill had a checkered military past prior to WWII — partly responsible for the British fiasco at Gallipoli, Turkey in WWI — he revived his career during WWII after winning election in 1940. Churchill gave inspirational radio speeches from rooftops though, for years, there were rumors that really he was safe in an underground bunker and someone else did the voiceover anyway because he was usually three sheets to the wind. However, Churchill’s “underground” war room was really only 12 feet underground, unbeknownst to Germany only a hundred yards from his residence at 10 Downing Street. It could’ve been obliterated on any night by a well-placed Luftwaffe bomb. His chair in the war room still has scars where he dug in his ring and fingernails during the Blitz, and visitors today can view the broom closet labeled “Churchill’s lavatory” where he maintained a special phone line to Roosevelt’s White House routed through a scrambler in the basement of Selfridge’s department store. Aside from his famous V for Victory sign, Churchill was fond of the acronym KBO, for “keep buggering on.”

Churchill symbolized fortitude and resilience at a vulnerable time. His famous speech regarding the courage of the RAF pilots, when he said that “never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few,” rang in the hearts of the people. This famous “We Shall Fight on the Beaches” speech captures the “British Bulldog’s” understated but defiant style, but hints toward the end that, while we’re definitely going to win…if we don’t hopefully the New World [America] will come to our rescue:

Keep Calm & Carry OnPilots had the most critical and dangerous high-profile job but many Brits, male and female and young and old, pitched in. Many women worked in munitions and building planes. Gallup polls showed that, even in their darkest hour, nearly all Britons thought they’d persevere and fend off Germany. Just to keep their chins up, the Ministry of Defense made posters to boost morale in the event of a German occupation. The most famous Keep Calm & Carry On incarnation came to light only in 2000, and another handful showed up on Antiques Roadshow. As mentioned, the Blitz might have been counterproductive, motivating the British to dig in their heels.

Supposedly, Germany never realized that the RAF was nearly at the end of their tether by the time Göring and Hitler gave up. At least that’s been English lore ever since. Recent scholarship based on simulation models suggests that the RAF wasn’t nearing defeat and that it was instead Germany who would’ve run out of planes within a few months. In any event, Operation Sea Lion (Germany’s proposed UK land invasion) never happened, stopping Germany’s momentum in the west, saving England from invasion, and arguably helping to defend America.

Map of Proposed German Invasion of England That Never Happened

Map of Proposed German Invasion of England That Never Happened; Instead the Reverse Happened Four Years Later with the Normandy Invasion.

Together, these “stiff upper-lipped” pilots, radar operators, munitions makers, and politicians held off the Luftwaffe. Hitler finally gave up and decided to attack England with rockets launched from France as he focused his efforts on invading the USSR. Der Führer later pointed to the Battle of Britain as the turning point in the war. Frustrated at their inability to defeat Britain through the air, Germany turned east and invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941 (Operation Barbarossa), dishonoring the Nazi-Soviet Pact of 1939. Hitler had planned this all along, but only after defeating Britain first. Germany’s Soviet invasion was welcome news all considered for the Western Allies but, still, it didn’t clear up Atlantic shipping lanes. Britain was still losing the Battle of the Atlantic by the summer of 1941, as “Wolfpacks” of German U-boats wreaked havoc on shipping from North America to Britain.

Interwar America
Winston Churchill desperately sought an American alliance. He said, “Hitler knows that he will have to break us in this island or lose the war…If we fail, then the whole world, including the United States, including all that we have known and cared for, will sink into the abyss of a new Dark Age.” But in Depression-era America, there was only lukewarm concern for the Nazi’s onslaught.

German-American Bund Marching in NYC, 1939, New York World Telegram Photo, Library of Congress

German-American Bund Marching in NYC, 1939, New York World Telegram Photo, Library of Congress

Despite its large German-American population, few Americans sided with Germany. The U.S. Nazi parties, the German American Bund and Free Society of Teutonia, were small and never posed a serious threat to U.S. security, despite being accepted enough to march in public parades. The FBI tracked them in the late 1930s and rolled them up once war broke out, retaining some of their spies as double agents. But if Nazism never caught on, neither were most Americans in the mood for intervening in another European war, especially because America’s stake in WWI was so muddled. Also, some American companies did business with the German Reich (e.g. GE, GM, Ford, DuPont, Kodak, Coca-Cola and Standard Oil) and an IBM subsidiary made Hollerith punch cards to help the Nazis catalog and track the movements of Jews in Germany (IBM & the Holocaust).

Hollywood, likewise, was hesitant at first to disrupt one of their best overseas markets. They used a clause in the 1934 Production Codes to “avoid offending citizens of any nation.” In this case, that meant crossing Joseph Goebbels’ Nazi Ministry of Popular Enlightenment and Propaganda. MGM usually screened their movies with Nazi leaders to make sure they were acceptable. They squelched a handful of informative documentaries. In the late 30’s, Jewish producers started to release films with negative portrayals of Nazis and their American sympathizers. With Confessions of a Nazi Spy (1939), Warner Brothers released the first American anti-Nazi movie aside from newsreels, after FDR pushed the State Department to remove restrictions.

Eternal Jew Poster

Eternal Jew Movie Poster

There’s a spirited scholarly debate about the extent of Hollywood studios’ collaboration with Nazis prior to 1938, before the Munich Conference, Austrian invasion, and Kristallnacht. Remember that, unlike Americans of the 1930s, we filter Nazis through the Holocaust and WWII. Comedian Charlie Chaplin, who was born the same week as Hitler (in 1889) and had a similar mustache, loathed them all along, and the feeling was mutual. Believing Chaplin was Jewish or at least a “pseudo-Jew,” Nazis derided the popular actor in Johann Von Leers’ 1933 book Jews Are Watching You and the book/movie The Eternal Jew (1937, 1940). Chaplin, in turn, brilliantly lampooned Hitler in The Great Dictator (1940), that he even courageously hoped to debut in Berlin. But not all Americans approved of such provocative propaganda. Joseph Kennedy, Sr., who as American ambassador to the United Kingdom supported the Munich Pact, tried to persuade movie directors to lay off the Nazis. In his opinion, Jewish Americans like the Warners were conspiring to lure the U.S. into an unwinnable and unnecessary war against Germany.

Charlie Chaplin in the Great Dictator, 1940

Charlie Chaplin in the Great Dictator, 1940

President Franklin Roosevelt was more anxious to oppose Hitler than most of Congress and the American public in the late 1930s, but even FDR wasn’t a full-fledged hawk. Due to voters’ skepticism about WWI, the Congressional Nye Committee outlawed American intervention in foreign wars in 1935. In 1937, they even went so far as to outlaw American aid to any allies at war, with the third round of the Neutrality Acts. Various American groups opposed intervention, including most conservatives, Southern and Midwestern farmers, and liberal student peace activists at Ivy League schools who espoused strength at home but no help for allies overseas. Yale’s America First Committee lobbied for isolationism and a Fortress America strategy of simply defending American shores. They recruited celebrities like aviator Charles Lindbergh, actress Lillian Gish, poet Robert Frost, producer Walt Disney, architect Frank Lloyd Wright, and future presidents Gerald Ford and John F. Kennedy. Offshoot groups of mothers with black veils lobbied congressmen to stay out of European affairs, with some yelling at them in the Capitol hallways and even spitting in their faces.

After all, the U.S. did have two large oceans on either side of it; perhaps it was time to take George Washington’s 1796 Farewell Address advice and steer clear of overseas commitments. Many WWI veterans (e.g. Disney) opposed any foreign intervention whatsoever. Even George Marshall, who later was Army Chief of Staff in WWII, opposed intervention until late 1941. Some bars near military bases banned soldiers. Generals testified on Capitol Hill in mufti (civilian clothes) to avoid provoking pacifist congressmen. Contrast either of those last two points with today, when merely walking through an airport in uniform can elicit a spontaneous round of applause.

"Is This What You Mean?" [by protection of two oceans in Fortress America model], Herblock, 1939, Library of Congress

“Is This What You Mean?” [by protection of two oceans in Fortress America model], Herblock, 1939, Library of Congress

While the U.S. was never purely isolationist in the 1920s and 30’s, its military was small and it was relatively isolationist in comparison to the late 1910s and early 40’s. By mid-1941, around 75% of Americans opposed intervention in WWII. But isolationist sentiment was predicated on a divided Europe where countries would fight each other. By 1940, Europe was mostly unified under German control. Cartoonist Herblock captured the situation perfectly in the 1939 cartoon above. If Britain fell and Japan attacked, George Washington’s two-ocean buffer idea could easily turn into a pincer. FDR realized that sooner than others did and even went so far as to produce a bogus map showing Germany’s intention to conquer America. People on the East Coast were naturally more concerned with Germany than were other parts of the country. South America, near the Panama Canal, was an additional concern because there were large German populations in Brazil and Argentina.

Hitler appreciated America for many reasons, including its natural resources, industrial strength, and racism. He admired Jim Crow, Indian reservations, and the 1924 Immigration Act. Moreover, he thought the hardiest type of Germans were the very ones who emigrated and helped settle America. Nonetheless, Hitler’s unpublished second book suggests he wanted to conquer the U.S. after first consolidating Europe. FDR didn’t know about the book, so his map was still bogus, but he was on the right track that Germany posed a threat. You could say that his map was a fib on behalf of a truth. Winston Churchill moved into the White House for weeks at a time to beg and plead that FDR take action. Hitler was now referring to Churchill, who was purportedly ¼ Mohawk Indian, as a “Jew-ridden American drunkard.”

Atlantic Convoy Routes, ca. 1941, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London

Against the wishes of the Pentagon, who feared the president would get impeached if the ploy failed, FDR maneuvered around the Neutrality Acts by sending Britain destroyers in exchange for little-used bases and with programs called Lend-Lease and Cash-And-Carry. Lend-Lease basically involved lending military equipment to Britain under the promise that they’d return it someday, but also sent aid to China and the USSR. FDR likened the program to lending a garden hose to a neighbor to put out a fire. When the neighbor was finished they could return it and, if it was damaged, they could compensate; in the meantime, the important thing was dousing the flames. Lend-Lease ended up providing Britain with ¼ of its subsequent armaments during the war and Hitler mentioned it as a cause for declaring war on the U.S. on December 11, 1941. With Cash-And-Carry, America sold weapons at its shore for cash or gold as long as the buyer wasn’t German or Japanese.

Britain, meanwhile, handed over eight of its North Atlantic and Caribbean bases to the U.S. and, most importantly for the long-term, dismantled its preferential trading system within the United Kingdom, opening up free trade for the U.S. down the road. That was a big concession for Winston Churchill because, according to some, it accelerated the ultimate collapse of Britain as the leading world economic power. Of the 50 destroyers that Britain received in exchange for the bases, none were built before 1919 and only nine were fit for service, leading one British commentator to complain that “the exchange of real estate and harbour facilities for obsolete rust-buckets in which men would be killed showed up the distinction between those that were fighting the war and those that were profiting from up.” Many Brits believed that, prior to 1918, the U.S. had mainly just profited from munitions production and war loans during the Great War and now seemed to be doing the same thing. As we saw at the top of the chapter, the U.S. didn’t forgive British war debts in the 1920s and 30’s and resentment over that, combined with anti-Semitism, contributed to a popular English meme of Uncle Sam as Uncle Shylock, from Shakespeare’s Jewish banker in The Merchant of the Venice. The Special Relationship between Britain and the U.S. played up by postwar historians and commentators included enough underlying tension that British officials had to launch a propaganda campaign aimed at getting its citizens to like America. Actors like Laurence Olivier promoted Lend Lease while radio and school curriculums taught Britons about American life, history, art, and popular music (folk, blues, and jazz), avoiding topics like the Neutrality Act and labor strikes that interfered with weapons production.

Mostly, American relations in 1940-41 underscore Britain’s desperation. Not only did the British make generous economic concessions to the U.S., they shared important technology. Led by Henry Tizard, the British placed big orders with American manufacturers in exchange for giving America’s government blueprints and equipment pertaining to radar, jet engines, submarine detection devices, superchargers (to allow planes to fly higher and faster), plastic explosives, gyroscopic (Norton) gun sights to account for bullet drop and wind, self-sealing fuel tanks (so planes could stay aloft after having their tank ruptured) and, most importantly, radioactive “super-bombs.” Already, the year before (1939), the Americans, British, and Canadians agreed to develop an atomic bomb with the Manhattan Project, hoping to beat Germany to the punch.

Finally, the Neutrality Act evaporated altogether as the U.S. occupied former British bases in Greenland and Iceland and Germany declared unrestricted submarine warfare in the Atlantic on merchant ships. The U.S. instituted a draft in 1940. American war hawks saw Britain as its last bastion of defense in Europe and didn’t want the Royal Navy falling into German hands, just as Churchill didn’t want to lose the French navy to the Germans. Even before the U.S. was officially at war, they lost several merchant vessels in the Battle of the Atlantic. FDR even instructed the Navy to hound the Germans to awaken the American public. German U-boats were under strict orders to not fire on American naval ships so as to not entice the U.S. into the war, as they had in WWI. These manufactured incidents baited the Germans into some small-scale attacks on American ships, including the USS Reuben James and USS Greer, but not enough to goad the public into favoring war with Germany. Many people didn’t like being goaded and Teddy Roosevelt’s daughter Alice even said she’d vote for Hitler over distant cousin FDR.

Still, the U.S. was now unrolling the fire-hoses for Britain, both figuratively and literally. They were shipping Britain actual fire-hoses and extending aid generally. FDR was slowly and deftly drawing the U.S. into a war its citizens weren’t ready for. During the 1940 campaign he dishonestly promised the public that, despite Lend-Lease, no American boys would fight overseas as they had in the Great War. But both FDR and GOP candidate Wendell Willkie agreed that a draft was a good idea, and Congress passed the resolution. FDR also poached key hawks from a Republican Party divided between hawks and isolationists, preparing to assemble a bipartisan wartime cabinet for his third term. In August 1941, four months before Pearl Harbor, FDR met Churchill off Newfoundland to sign the Atlantic Charter, a pronouncement of their mutual dedication to protect democracy and promote liberal ideas globally after the war (critics said the charter was so vague that even Stalin later signed it). FDR also accepted American responsibility for protecting or trying to protect the shipping lanes between North America and Iceland, taking some pressure off the Royal Navy. Months before direct involvement, the U.S. was already losing ships, making promises about the postwar world, and drafting soldiers, and the government-subsidized munitions industry was pulling the U.S. out of the Great Depression. Nonetheless, polls showed that, as of December 6, 1941 (the day before Pearl Harbor), ¾ of Americans favored neutrality.

BloodchitBack To Asia
Meanwhile, the U.S. helped China fight Japan and even had a group of 100 volunteers, the Flying Tigers (AVG), supporting China’s Aviation Corps, reminiscent of the Lafayette Escadrille in France before the U.S. entered WWI and the Eagle Squadrons flying for the RAF during the Battle of Britain. In their iconic Curtiss P-40 Warhawks, these early entrants into WWII helped draw off Japanese resources from their Pacific campaigns. The bloodchit above explains to civilians that they should rescue, protect, and provide medical care to American pilots.

3rd Squadron Hell's Angels Flying Tigers, 1942, San Diego Air & Space Museum Archive (this group later formed the famous motorcycle gang of the same name)

3rd Squadron Hell’s Angels Flying Tigers, 1942, San Diego Air & Space Museum Archive (this group later formed the famous motorcycle gang of the same name)

United China Relief Poster

Poster Encouraging Americans to Contribute to China’s War Against Japan

Marines in China later learned to be “gung-ho” — to cooperate well — though the term later morphed into meaning enthusiastic. But the lobbies that stood to gain selling oil and metal to Japan were still dictating American policy, even as the U.S. sided with China. That, despite the fact that there was already some indication of a future conflict between Japan and America. During the Moscow Trials of 1936-38 concerning a Trotskyist plot to overthrow Joseph Stalin, it came to light that Japan was working with the rebels and hoped to sign an oil deal with the new Russian leaders. That would relieve them of their dependence on American oil and allow them to stockpile reserves in the event of a future U.S. war. While those revelations didn’t do much to disrupt relations initially, and the Russian rebels were shot anyway in Stalin’s Great Purge, oil was indeed the indirect cause of war between Japan and the U.S.

South of China, Japanese expansion into Indochina (Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia) threatened American-held oil interests in nearby Indonesia, then known as the Dutch East Indies. The U.S. had already cut Japan off from aeronautical equipment in the “moral embargoes” after their China invasion. When Japan invaded northern Indochina and signed the Tripartite Pact with Germany in September 1940, the U.S. cut off aviation fuel and steel/scrap metal to both countries and froze Japanese assets in American banks. The U.S. had also sold millions of tons of scrap metal to Nazi Germany in the late 1930s. When Japan invaded southern Indochina in July 1941, American oil companies had seen enough, especially Socony Vacuum/Jersey Standard, a subsidiary of Standard, the company now known as ExxonMobil and Chevron. They had wells, refineries, and stations in Dutch Indonesia, and felt threatened by Japan’s invasion of Indochina to the west.

Station in Indonesia, Dutch Museum of World Cultures

Station in Indonesia, Dutch Museum of World Cultures

FDR “put the noose around Japan’s neck” just enough they’d feel the tug, by embargoing all crude oil unless Japan retreated out of Southeast Asia and China. Japan later claimed they considered this an act of war, which it wasn’t, but it did back them into a corner. As one historian put it, the “oil clock was ticking” on Japan after the embargo. They could offset America’s scrap metal embargo some by importing from Central and South America but were running out of fuel, the lifeblood of modern industry and militaries. They either had to give up their imperial ambitions and retreat or go for broke and try to knock the U.S. and Britain out of the Pacific so they could take the oil for themselves. Peru’s Japanese ambassador even told American Ambassador Joseph Grew that he overheard leaders discussing a sneak attack on Pearl Harbor later that year.

Pearl Harbor, Oahu

Pearl Harbor, Oahu, Hawaii

Pearl Harbor
Japan’s leaders disagreed on what to do. Hawks in Parliament pushed for war while, prior to 1940, naval commander Isoroku Yamamoto feared “awakening the sleeping tiger” by provoking America. He had studied and worked in the U.S., spoke fluent English, and admired its culture and industrial capacity. He didn’t think Japan could win a prolonged war with the U.S. Yamamoto adamantly opposed the alliance with Germany and supported the disarmament agreements with the West in the 1920s and 30’s, making him such an enemy of right-wing militarists that they considered assassinating him. Being named commander of the Combined Fleet likely saved his life as it temporarily put him out of harm’s way.

Isoroku Yamamoto

Japan resolved to deliver a preemptive knockout blow to the U.S. Navy by destroying its Pacific Fleet in Pearl Harbor, on Oahu — the spot that, thirty-five years earlier, Franklin’s cousin Teddy Roosevelt prophesied the Japanese would attack before trying to conquer the Philippines. Of course, before we declare TR too much of a Nostradamus on this score, we should remember that Pearl Harbor was the main American naval base in the Pacific. Led by Admiral Harry Yarnell, the Navy ran their own mock raid on Pearl Harbor in 1932 (on a Sunday morning, no less) with biplanes taking off from aircraft carriers and dropping flares and flour sacks. In fact, Warner Brothers was shooting a movie called Across the Pacific about a fictional Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in the fall of 1941 that they moved to the Panama Canal when the real attack occurred on December 7th.

FDR moved the main fleet to Pearl Harbor from San Diego in 1940 to discourage Japanese aggression, but the opposite happened. His repositioning of the Navy changed Admiral Yamamoto’s mind; he argued that, while its location in the central Pacific threatened Japan, so too it made it vulnerable to a Japanese attack. Yamamoto even hoped a brutal attack’s impact would lower “the morale of the U.S. Navy and the American people…to such an extent that it cannot be recovered.” By fall 1941, Yamamoto was conflicted, still hoping for peace with the U.S. but favoring Pearl Harbor as the best way to poke the sleeping tiger if, indeed, the sleeping tiger must be poked. He even threatened to resign if the skeptical Chief of the Naval General Staff, Admiral Osami Nagano, didn’t approve the attack. Nagano feared a counter-attack would expose Japan’s carrier fleet. “What a strange position I find myself in,” Yamamoto wrote a friend, “having been assigned the mission diametrically opposed to my own personal opinion, with no choice but to push full speed in pursuance of that mission. Alas, is that fate?”

The U.S. learned that the main Japanese fleet had left Tokyo in late November but didn’t know where they were. Many analysts figured they’d attack the most vulnerable Americans stationed in the Philippines and some ships left Pearl Harbor to defend the Philippines. Roosevelt guessed they’d attack British Malaya or Burma. Instead, six Japanese carriers were steaming toward Hawaii in an amazing feat of logistics. Sailing thousands of miles over rough seas, they had to refuel three times from supply tankers without breaking radio silence. As a decoy, Japanese diplomats flew to Washington to discuss a potential withdrawal from China. In Hawaii, Japanese tourists had gone up in planes and taken pictures of how the U.S. Navy arranged its boats and planes, huddled together for protection, so as to make them easier to guard. Unfortunately, that arrangement only made them more vulnerable to being destroyed in rapid succession. While U.S. Navy brass that favored destroyers over aircraft carriers ignored Harry Yarnell’s 1932 mock raid launched from carriers, Yamamoto didn’t. The Japanese even positioned their boats in the same place and followed his route of flying in from the northern part of the island on a Sunday morning. Taking advantage of their new alliance, Japan also used German intelligence to study the first real attack on a city launched from an aircraft carrier: the Royal Navy’s Battle of Taranto (Italy) in 1940. The U.S. Office of Navy Intelligence also had a map showing that the British used aerial torpedoes successfully in shallow water at Taranto — critical information that should’ve been passed on to the Navy at Pearl Harbor since they were under the false impression that their shallow waters precluded such an attack.

Pearl Harbor Carrier Chart

Pearl Harbor Carrier Chart from Reports of General MacArthur, Prepared by his General Staff

On their way to Pearl Harbor, Japanese pilots were falsely told the U.S. had already declared war on Japan. As the attack commenced, diplomats who’d supposedly come to Washington to talk peace delivered a letter to Secretary of State Cordell Hull accusing America of dishonoring Japan by refusing to recognize their sacrifices and attempt to bring about order, stability, and peace in Asia. Torpedo dive-bombers (Nakajima “Kates”) and fighters (Mitsubishi Zeros) attacked moored ships and air bases across Oahu in two waves. Japan’s navy had modified a new type of shallow-water torpedo that the U.S. didn’t know about and American underwater nets were all down to make it easier for boats to get around the harbor.

Naval Dispatch from the Commander in Chief Pacific (CINCPAC) Announcing the Japanese Attack on Pearl Harbor, 7 December 1941, John J. Ballentine Papers

Naval Dispatch from the Commander in Chief Pacific (CINCPAC) Announcing the Japanese Attack on Pearl Harbor, 7 December 1941, John J. Ballentine Papers

The U.S. sank a Japanese sub off the coast an hour before the bombing started on December 7th but commanders didn’t consider that an unusual enough occurrence that it indicated a broader attack. Radar operators also picked up some signals but radar was new at the time and their commanders wrote off the signals as American boats and planes arriving from the mainland. The serene Hawaiian setting created a sense of complacency on American bases and most of the soldiers and sailors were teenagers with no serious expectation of an imminent battle — especially a surprise attack when the two countries weren’t at war.

USS Arizona, Pearl Harbor, 12.7.41

USS Arizona, Pearl Harbor, 12.7.41

Two-thousand-four-hundred Americans died that Sunday morning, over half on the USS Arizona after a bomb ignited its forward magazine. Hundreds of sailors jumped off their boats into the harbor but much of it was covered with burning oil. The USS Oklahoma capsized, trapping its men underneath as water seeped into the compartments. When rescue workers cut through the hull later that night, their torches consumed what little oxygen was left. Other sailors were trapped for weeks and died in the hull of the USS West Virginia. When Hawaiians rushed to the bases to offer assistance, many were killed in an unfortunate case of misidentification and friendly fire.

Japanese Navy Mitsubishi A6M2 "Zero" Fighter Takes Off From the Aircraft Carrier Akagi, 1941

Like the 9/11 attack 60 years later, Pearl Harbor could’ve been far worse. Not only had three American carriers — the USS Lexington, Enterprise, and Saratoga — left the base, but the Japanese called off a final, third sortie that might have exploded the Navy’s fuel storage tanks at Ford Island, hindering America’s capacity to fight in 1942. And they missed the repair depots that the Navy used to fix damaged ships. The Japanese were also disappointed that the fleet wasn’t at the deeper harbor in Lahaina, Maui; Pearl Harbor was shallower (only 30-40 ft.) and the U.S. surfaced and salvaged most of their ships. In fact, all the American ships damaged at Pearl Harbor were in service at the end of the war except the Arizona, Oklahoma, and Utah, whereas all the Japanese ships in the attack were sunk during the war.

In retrospect — and hindsight is always 20/20 — there were clues of an impending attack and mistakes made in failing to notify Hawaii as quickly as officials might have. However, contrary to common lore, there is no persuasive evidence that FDR knew about the location ahead of time and let it happen. Conspiracy theories spread that FDR deliberately failed to warn the Navy, just as “Truthers” with overactive imaginations and weak standards of evidence blamed George W. Bush for planning 9/11. British agent Dušan Popov tried to warn FBI director J. Edgar Hoover that they had picked up on rumors of a Pearl Harbor attack and that the Japanese were asking Germany if they knew how the depth of Pearl Harbor compared to Taranto and if Pearl had anti-torpedo nets. Hoover was fascinated by the microdot technology Popov’s information was on but didn’t trust him because he was a double agent who also worked for Germany. Commanders in Hawaii never learned what Popov told the FBI (Popov may have been Ian Fleming’s inspiration for James Bond). Moreover, officials in Washington withheld — or at least, amidst bureaucratic confusion and ineptitude, never conveyed — vital information in order to not reveal that they’d broken the Japanese code, including that Japanese were spying on the Navy at Pearl Harbor and suggesting that they were planning an attack if negotiations didn’t improve by November 25th. Ten days prior to December 7th, Chief of Naval Operations Harold Stark issued a general warning to all Pacific Navy bases that they suspected an attack somewhere. Japanese diplomats indicated to the Americans and British beforehand that war was imminent, arguing that to secure their empire, they “must take measures to secure the materials of the South Seas.”

Also like 9/11, finger-pointing commenced immediately, with officers on the ground in Hawaii (rightfully) blaming military brass in Washington for not keeping them fully informed and brass blaming the Hawaiian bases for being unprepared. Court martials followed that wasted time and money while unfairly scapegoating the leaders in charge of Pearl Harbor: Pacific Fleet Commander Husband Kimmel and Army Field Command Walter Short, ruining both of their careers and reputations. In 1944, chief cryptologist Laurance Safford told Kimmel that top brass withheld background information from them in order to preserve knowledge of Operation Magic’s code-breaking. U.S. spies were too focused on Japanese diplomats, though, assuming they’d talk about specific war plans and not realizing that their military didn’t trust their foreign ministry with information. Still, information came in on the night of December 6th-7th indicating an attack and by early in the morning even the location. However, by the time everyone at Operation Magic got out of bed and Stark, FDR, and Army Chief of Staff George Marshall pieced the cobbled messages together, figured out what was going on, and transcribed each other’s messy handwriting, they sent a telegram via Western Union that ended up being delivered by a bicycle courier to Kimmel eight hours after the attack. It wasn’t even marked priority! Kimmel was cleared of charges after the war but never regained his rank. No, FDR didn’t deliberately withhold information about Pearl Harbor, but the dereliction of duty charges that besmirched Kimmel and Short’s reputations should’ve been aimed at their superiors, if anyone.

In any event, FDR had his wish of getting America into the war, even though he was disappointed that Germany wasn’t involved in the attack because Hitler concerned him more than the Japanese did. Americans on the East Coast feared a German attack, though, and New York City had two air raid sirens the next day that proved to be false alarms.

USS West Virginia at Pearl Harbor, 7 December 1941. U.S. Naval History & Heritage Command

USS West Virginia at Pearl Harbor, 7 December 1941, U.S. Naval History & Heritage Command

Gradually, over the course of the afternoon of December 7th, FDR came to realize the magnitude of the Pearl Harbor attack. Having served as Assistant Secretary of the Navy, he was familiar with the specific ships that went down. He personally laid the keel for the Arizona. Roosevelt worried that his legacy would be overseeing one of the worst days in that branch’s history, with the Navy having lost more sailors on December 7th than they had during all of WWI. After struggling for hours to get through, the White House finally made contact with General Douglas MacArthur in the Philippines to warn him that they were probably next. MacArthur, who fancied himself as having keen insight into the “oriental mind,” assured them that nothing similar could happen on his watch.

Americans united around the war effort — at least as united as they ever get. Pacifist numbers dwindled to insignificant numbers as all 450 chapters of America First disbanded. Charles Lindbergh, for instance, flew missions against Japan. Henry Ford severed ties with Nazi Germany, apologized for his publication of the International Jew (Chapter 7), and renounced anti-Semitism. John Kennedy immediately enlisted, lying about his poor health. Republican leadership quickly rallied around Roosevelt and the war effort, including his opponent in the 1940 election, Wendell Willkie.

FDR explained to his cabinet that the U.S. was on the verge of its biggest conflict since the Civil War, even as he soft-pedaled details about the severity of the attack. Three of Roosevelt’s sons volunteered for combat that day. With all his writers out of town for the weekend, FDR set about writing a speech he delivered to a joint session of Congress the next day. The cabinet tossed around the idea of declaring war on all three Axis Powers (Japan, Germany, and Italy), but decided to focus just on Japan. FDR’s Secretary of State, Cordell Hull (D), and Secretary of War, Henry Stimson (R), were dismayed that the speech was so short. They wanted a thorough case made against Japan, including a laundry list of Japanese transgressions. But FDR wisely chose to keep it simple and overrode the unanimous advice of his senior cabinet. As he worked on the speech, a doctor rubbed cocaine along his nasal membrane to clear his sinuses, while Eleanor spoke first to the public on the radio about Pearl Harbor. She laid the groundwork for Franklin’s speech the next day by explaining that Americans would be sacrificing their lives for the country in a long upcoming struggle.

First Draft of "Day of Infamy" Speech, FDR Library, Marist College

First Draft of “Day of Infamy” Speech, FDR Library, Marist College

By the time FDR awoke the next day to give his “Day of Infamy” Speech, Winston Churchill had already declared war on Japan after he learned they attacked British forces in the southwest Pacific. While General MacArthur had assured FDR he was on full alert in the Philippines, he was inexplicably caught off guard by a Japanese attack there that wiped out half his air corps before it got off the ground. Yet, unlike the Hawaiian commanders who had no warning, “Mac” kept his job and went on to become a war hero.

It had been a long 24 hours for FDR, considering that early on the afternoon of December 7th, he’d been working on his stamp collection. The Treasury Department lent gangster Al Capone’s old car with bulletproof windows to escort FDR to the capital because they weren’t sure if the Japanese would try to assassinate him. At this point, no one knew if the Japanese were on the verge of attacking the West Coast or what would happen next. With his trademark leg braces, cane, and son at his side to support him, FDR entered the House Chamber and slowly limped to the podium to rally the largest audience in American radio history.

Congress declared war within an hour; WWI had taken four days. Hitler figured that the U.S. could hardly fight two wars at once, and Germany declared war on America days later. Hitler thought the war was won, especially given that Japan hadn’t lost a war in 3k years. Now the Germans could disrupt American shipping to Britain with impunity and the U.S. would presumably be too preoccupied with Japan to offset that advantage by threatening Germany. In addition, Germany was allied with Japan as part of their Tripartite Pact and their alliance mandated that Germany and Italy declare war on the U.S. since America was at war with Japan. Hitler reaffirmed his support of Japan after Pearl Harbor. He’d been trashing and mocking FDR’s speeches since April 1939:

Hitler’s infatuation with America had long since evaporated. He dreamt of bombing New York City and said, “My feelings against America are those of hatred and repugnance – half-Judaized, half-negrified, with everything built on the dollar.” The propaganda poster below shows the conflicted and warped Nazi view of the U.S., simultaneously critical of both the KKK and African Americans. Nearly overnight, America found itself in two wars at once.Nazi View of America

Optional Reading & Viewing:
Inter-War Diplomacy, 1921-1936, State Department, Office of the Historian
Diplomacy & the Road to Another War, 1937-1945, State Department, Office of the Historian
U.S. Holocaust Museum Exhibits, Smithsonian
Becky Evans, “Paris Through a Nazi’s Lens,” Daily Mail, 9.11.13
Nick Baumann, “Chamberlain Was Right,” Slate, 9.28.18
Richard Brownell, “The Tizard Mission: The Briefcase That Changed World War II,” WETA History Blog
Ian Toll, “A Reluctant Enemy,” [Yamamoto], New York Times, 12.6.11

Selections From Frank Capra’s Wartime Propaganda Series, Why We Fight: